The Mets made official what we expected for the last week and fired General Manager Omar Minaya and Manager Jerry Manuel. Today lets take a look at the oft nebulous and bench and bullpen.
As opposed to their American league counterparts with their socialist designated hitters, a National League bench and bullpen are more difficult to construct. Though this is probably an oversimplification, a bench player should offer a couple of the following qualities; pinch hitting ability, power, speed, defense, ability to spot start or fill-in due to injury. Here’s who likely to return next season from the current roster.
The Bench:1B/OF - Chris Carter: “The Animal” as he was affectionately known finally got a look at the Major League level this year. He’s a solid bat with some power from the left side, showed the ability to pinch hit and spot start when needed, and his intensity and preparation impressed his teammates. I’d like to see “The Animal” use that intensity and hard work to improve his glaring lack of defensive prowess, however.
1B/OF - Nick Evans: Nick is out of options, and therefore cannot be sent to the Minor Leagues without being exposed on waivers to all other major league teams. He’s come close to breaking camp with the Major League club before. His value is similar to Carter’s, except with a right handed bat.
2B/SS - Joaquin Arias: I wish the Mets had given Arias more of a look down the stretch. He was once a highly touted prospect in the Yankees organization who was the player to be named later in the Alfonso Soriano for A-Rod trade. At 25 years old and with only 275 plate appearances in his career, it’s difficult to say what, exactly, Arias is. Regardless, you have to figure he can provide more value than Alex Cora as your utility middle infielder.
Give ‘Em the Heave Ho:Fernando Tatis is not under contract for next year, and I don’t think you’ll see him in a Met uniform come Spring Training.
Potential Free Agents:That leaves room on the bench for a back-up catcher, and legitimate defensive centerfielder (to spell Beltran & Pagan) and speed threat.
C - Rod Barajas: During the first half of 2010 the Mets got a bargain in Barajas, who signed a one year / $500K contract. Nagging injury and just being kind of old for an everyday catcher grind Barajas’ production to a halt and the Mets allowed him to be claimed off waivers. Barajas could really flourish in a back-up role. I really think he got burnt out as a 35 year old everyday catcher last season. Plus he’d be a good mentor for Thole. He did play well in limited action for the Dodgers, so you have to figure there will be a market for his services. But expect him to sign another one year deal for less than $1 million.
C - Jose Molina: The Blue Jays hold a $1.2 million option on Molina for 2011. It seems kind of silly to spend that much on a back-up catcher, but there’s a chance the Jays lose John Buck, who had a very solid bounce back year, to free agency. If they do, expect top prospect J.P. Arencibia to take over full time duty. Either way, they may overpay to keep the solid Molina brother in house.
C - Non Tender Candidates: A couple interesting non-tender candidates include Brayan Pena and Humberto Quintero.
C - Henry Blanco: If all else fails the Mets could bring back Blanco on the cheap. He’s got some pop, calls a good game and is well respected in the clubhouse. Plus him and Johan have a good report from their days in Minnesota.
Although this is a low on the Mets list of priorities, they should still take care and pick a suitable candidate. Josh Thole’s continued development defensively is critical to the Mets future success. So, if I were in the front office, I’d ask around the league and find out who’d be a good mentor while also providing some value statistically.
The center field market looks to be pretty thin with the only viable candidate being:
OF - Jody Gerut: Gerut is coming off pretty dismal season, albeit in very limited action. But he is above average defensively and has proved to have some worth as a left handed bat in the past. He signed a one year / $2 million deal with the Brewers last season. I can’t imagine him getting any offers over $1 million for one year, and probably on a minor league deal at that.
In House Candidates: The Mets best option may be in letting Jason Pridie and Jesus Feliciano fight it out in Spring Training. Feliciano raked at Triple-A this year, basically forcing the Mets’ hand in giving him a shot in the Majors. He was okay in just over 100 plate appearances, but his defense rates better in right field than in center.
Pridie was selected off waivers by the Mets in February. He performed well through late June at Triple-A, before injury derailed his season. His slash line of .286 / .342 / .389 is good, not great. As former 2nd round pick, there’s definitely potential still there.
The Bullpen:Out of all the moving parts that make up a professional base-balling team, I think the bullpen is the hardest to construct. First, the role of the bullpen has changed radically in the last twenty years. Traditionally, the bullpen was where you stuck your ‘tweeners; guys who were good enough to pitch in the Major Leagues, yet not good enough to be a starting pitcher. The 1970’s and 1980’s brought about the advent of the closer. However, guys like Bruce Sutter, Goose Gossage and Rollie Fingers would routinely pitch 2-3 innings to get a save, and wrack up more than 100 IP for the season. A phenomenon completely unheard of nowadays.
For better or for worse, guys are actually groomed as relief pitchers/closers from high school and college on. So while the art of relief pitching is still evolving and becoming more advanced, relief pitching performance is still wildly erratic from year-to-year. A successful bullpen is, more often than not, a motley crew of veterans, rookies, and guys signed to minor league contracts. Building a bullpen is an inexact science so any organization’s best bet is to stockpile arms and try and find the best possible combination.
From everything I’ve read I also think it best to assign pitchers specific roles. Most pitchers don’t like being jerked around, not knowing when and in what situations they may be called upon to pitch. Shocking, I know. I find these classifications silly and arbitrary, but if helps pitcher performance than I’m all for it. Let’s take a look at who will be returning next season:
CL - Francisco Rodriguez: K-Rod’s legal / anger management issues aside, I have to assume he will be on the active roster next season. Unless Frankie serves jail time, it’s safe to say he will be the team’s closer next year. Before his reprehensible father-in-law punching, and creepy stalker mass texting incidents, Mr. Rodriguez was, statistically speaking, having an excellent season. He had 25 saves, struck out more than a batter per inning, giving up 7 hits per 9 innings pitched with K/BB ration of over 3:1.
SU [RHP] - Bobby Parnell: Parnell settled in nicely this year and I think it’s safe to say that the Parnell as starting pitcher experiment is over. He struck out nearly a batter per inning (33 K / 35 IP) while walking a scant eight batters. He let up a tad too many hits (41) but he’s still developing. Parnell’s high K/9 IP and very good K/BB ratios are an indicator of future success.
MR [RHP] - Ryota Igarashi: Mr. Igarashi is under contract for one more year. After a hot start his season got sidetracked with a hamstring injury it seems he never fully recovered from. He looked dominant at times, completely lost at others. Who knows if he breaks camp with the big league squad next year, but he will be a part of the bullpen at some point. Walks seem to be his biggest issue. In 35 IP last year he gave up 20 hits, struck out 25 while walking 18. If he can find some control, somehow, he could be an effective reliever.
MR [RHP] - Manny Acosta: The Mets claimed Acosta off waivers from the Braves prior to the 2010 season and was literally a steal. In 39.2 IP he struck out 42, gave up only 30 hits and walked 18. All good for an ERA+ of 134. His Batting Average on Balls in Play was .283, a tad below the mean of .300, so there was probably a little bit of luck involved. But he’s still under team control for another year, meaning he’s cheap and will provide value beyond his salary.
MR [RHP] - Sean Green: Since being acquired from the Mariners in the J.J. Putz deal, Green has been pretty not very good at pitching a baseball. He was hurt last year, and pretty much all of this year. Plus he changed his delivery during the off season so I’m willing to give him a pass. He’s entering his second arbitration year, and won’t receive a raise from his $975K salary with no body of work this year so he’ll be pretty cheap. He will be on the roster next year, possibly starting the year at Triple A, and hopefully, healthy he can show the Mets what he can do. If he stinks then they’ll just non-tender him next year.
In House Candidates:LHP - Mike O’Connor: O’Connor was a 7th round pick of the Expos in 2002. He actually started 20 games for the Nationals in 2006, but only saw a cup of coffee at the major league level after that. The Mets signed him as a minor league free agent and he had an excellent year at Triple A, pitching to a 2.67 ERA in 70 IP with 70 K’s. He also held righties to a .231 BAA so he’s not necessarily just a lefty specialist. With the Mets potentially losing both Pedro Feliciano and Hisanori Takahashi to free agency, O’Connor deserves a look.
RHP - Chad Cordero: Another minor league free agent and former Expo/National. Cordero was 1st round pick in 2003 who saw Major League action the same year he was drafted. He was a very effective closer 2004 - 2007 before his arm blew up in 2008. He’s kicked around the Mariners minor league system before the Mets signed him in July. He pitched well in 16 IP, striking out 15 with a 1.69 ERA. I don’t think he’ll make the big league team, but he’s a solid option to have down on the farm for the inevitable injury or ineffectiveness.
LHP - Raul Valdes: The Mets got Valdes on loan from the Mexican league and he provided value out of the bullpen. His ERA (4.91) and peripheral stats are nothing to write home about, but he’s got a rubber arm, and can eat innings out of the bullpen.
Re-Signees:LHP - Hisanori Takahashi: What a pleasant surprise Takahashi turned out to be. He had success in every role the Mets asked him to fill; starter, reliever, set-up man, closer. His stats are a little skewed because he got exposed as a starting pitcher, but as a reliever he posted a 2.01 ERA in 57.1 IP with 60 K’s and 22 BB. The rub is that Takahashi may want the opportunity to start. If a team is willing to give him that opportunity, then he may walk.
LHP - Pedro Feliciano: Pedro is entering free agency for the first time this year. He’s a work horse, leading the league and setting the club record for appearances with 92. He’s also extremely effective against lefties, and in a division that includes Ryan Howard, Chase Utley, Jason Heyward and Adam Dunn that is extremely valuable. On the con side Feliciano is 34 years old and made $2.9 million this year. He’s due for a raise and will probably be seeking a multi-year deal. He projects as a Type B free agent, so the Mets will offer arbitration. I’d try and work out a reasonable deal, and if he walks then take the draft pick. Even though the relief pitching market is never very strong, locking in a lefty specialist in his mid 30’s for multiple years at $4 million plus per year seems like a waste of money.
RHP - Elmer Dessens: Dessens signed a minor league deal with the Mets for $700K, his second consecutive for the Mets. He pitched well in 2009 and 2010 with a 3.31 ERA and 2.30 ERA in 32.2 IP and 47 IP respectively. But Dessens doesn’t strike out many batters (14 in 2009, 16 in 2010) and his BAbip of .196 and .243 in those seasons suggests his success is a byproduct of luck and good defense, more so than his skill. If the Mets can get him on another minor league deal for cheap, then I’d go for it. Otherwise I’d let him walk for a more lucrative deal, especially at 39 years old.
Free Agents:The relief pitching market is notoriously shitty. There’s a good chance any decent reliever is a Type A free agent. I, personally, don’t see the value of giving up draft picks for a pitcher you hope throws 60 -70 innings quality innings. So either you overpay in dollars, years, draft picks or all three. Any Type B free agents are probably pretty good too, in which case they’re looking for dollars and years. After that you hope that you can pick up a reclamation project off the scrap heap.
None of these scenarios are ideal, which proves my point that building an effective bullpen is really difficult. In my opinion, the Mets could most use one more dependable left hander (since they’re liable to lose Feliciano and/or Takahashi) and one more dependable right hander. The cash strapped Mets will have to get creative and go bargain hunting:
LHP: Professional fatso
Dennys Reyes is coming off a 2 year / $3 million deal so he doesn’t figure to be that expensive. He pitched well for St. Louis, but didn’t log a ton of innings either year and will be 34 next year. His high BB/9 IP rate is not ideal either.
Joe Beimel is in the same boat as Reyes; enjoyed some success, will be relatively cheap (coming off a 1 year / $850K contract), but is 34, doesn’t strike guys out while walking too many. You can lump guys like
Ron Mahay and
Will Ohman into this category too. The best option for the Mets is
Randy Choate. He’ll be a Type B free agent, so he won’t cost a draft pick. He made 85 appearances for the Rays this season, with a 8.1 K / 9 average. He’ll be eligible for free agency for the first time. So while he’ll be due a raise, his previous salary of $700K will make him cheaper than Feliciano.
RHP: I would love the Mets to go after
Jesse Crain or
Jon Rauch to shore up their bullpen. But both are making $2 million or more this year, Crain is coming off another solid campaign, Rauch has bolstered his value by closing part of the year for the Twins, and both are in their prime.
Koji Uehara has been excellent for the Orioles since transferring to the bullpen. While he won’t command his previous $5 million salary as a relief pitcher, he doesn’t figure to be cheap either. Instead, bet on the Mets looking for guys coming off injuries or down years like
Juan Cruz (who the Royals figure to buy out for $500K),
Scott Shields (though he may retire),
Mike MacDougal, or
Tyler Walker. One feasible option may be
Jose Contreras. The Phillies signed him to a one year / $1.5 million contract last year so he doesn’t figure to be that expensive. At 39 years old you wouldn’t think a multi-year contract is in order either, and he still provides value (9.1 K/9, 1.218 WHIP, 3.56 K/BB ratio) out of the bullpen.